Page 25 - 10x GOOD_Issue 3_V4
P. 25

Evaluate
                          Ipsative Loop           Result 1           Ipsative Loop




            Activity Attempt         Immediate          Activity Attempt         Immediate         Compar

                     1                Feedback                   2                Feedback         e Result
                                                                                                     1 & 2





 speed and reps are what power   Curious is by far the best way for   just feels good to be good - to beat
 human attractions to Tetris, golf,   humans to memorize key/common   the challenge.
 and knitting. Luckily, I had already   terms and things like math facts.
 adopted a mindset of speed and   And they love playing it.   I quickly realized that by not giving
 reps in my class pedagogy, so I            students immediate feedback, we
 was able to see the beauty of The   Here’s why kids aren’t gaining   were actually disenfranchising them
 Forgetting Curve immediately. (To   these skill in the normal “turn in   from the game of school. No score,
 help shift your mindset, try reading   your work” model. Humans crave   no curiosity. Their OCD never kicks
 17 Ways Football is Better than High   feedback. And they want it fast.   in. Now that worksheet isn’t a quest
 School by Herb Childress (https://  Why do we have all that sports data   - it’s a chore. As educators, we are
 websites.umich.edu/~psycours/561/  on screen now? Because people   not leveraging the ipsative nature of
 childress.htm). Herb’s work explains   want to KNOW. And they want to   learning.
 why the same kids will not work in   know now. How fast was that pitch?
 class and then go work super hard   How long was the hang time on that   I returned to the classroom for one
 in football (or band or ag) one hour   punt? What is the F1 car speed,   glorious year during the height
 later. Circa 1998. We’ve known the   when is he hitting the brake what’s   of COVID. I had been doing a lot
 answer for decades, but we can’t   his split lap time?  (hundreds) of Fast and Curious
 change the direction of the ship           demos - but this class was a long-
 heading over the cliff.  But in school - we put things in a   term study project. One of my
          box and wait. Sometimes we never   students was very well known for his
 The Ebbinghaus Effect says that if   get a grade or any feedback. When   non-participation. He did nothing for
 people do something four times over   we deny feedback, we interdict a   the first four weeks of school - but   (you earn money in-game for going
 four days, their retention zooms   immediately to read back the 3-5   used it with 4 and a half-year-olds   basic human question: how did I do?  slowly, I got his gamer side plugged   on winning streak and accumulating
 from the low teens to the high 80%   most missed items. I try to give a   and school superintendents. I’ve   I was doing the Fast and Curious   into the games. He started playing,   points).
 range. This is what had happened on   mnemonic or an example on the   had 400+ people who don’t speak   in India and Dr Sunita Gandhi said   he rose up the ranks. At the end of
 my Latin Roots quiz with my class:   missed items. Then we play again,   Turkish at all move from 0% to 40%   to me: well isn’t this just ipsative   the semester, we did the same 45-  Why don’t more teachers approach
 we did the test daily, with immediate   immediately. The score will typically   to 96% on Turkish foods in under 10   learning (https://psychology.fandom.  word Latin Roots quiz I used to do   their class instruction this way?
 feedback. So simple.  bump up 20-25 points.  minutes.   com/wiki/Ipsative_assessment)?   with my 8th graders. But now it was   The Ebbinhaus Effect/Forgetting
          Fabulous! And I said…what’s that?   in Gimkit. On average, the students   Curve and Ipsative learning are well
 So, here’s how I leverage the   Tuesday - repeat.  Teachers will ask: aren’t they just   She explained the basics of the idea.   answered about 108 questions   known in all parts of our life except
 Ebbinghaus Effect/Forgetting Curve   Wednesday - repeat.   memorizing? My response is that   It’s learning from yourself. Just like   each on a quiz with 45 words. The   for school. I believe we labor under
 in my classroom:  On Thursday, the class might be   I’ve been waiting for my entire   in Solitaire. Or Pac-Man. You play.   class average was 92%. My non-  the misconception that more time
 at 90% and then we do the final   career to have kids memorize certain   You get a score. You consider ways   participator ended up tops in the   on a singular task is “better” learning
 Monday - here’s the quiz. Go. No   rep. Not there yet? We will play on   academic elements - and we’ve   to get a better score. Then you play   class - he’d answered 139 questions   when it turns out that 6 minutes a
 pre-teach at all. Most classes will   Friday.  been trying all manner of failure   again. And again. You play over and   (doing the quiz almost 3 times in   day is far more effective. I know that
 finish the first round in the 25-40%   on this: flashcards, memory games,   over because you want a better   under 15 minutes) only missed five   we think we need to grade “after
 range. We’ve only been in class   This phenomenon works in all   crosswords, word searches, writing   score. What does the high score give   total questions and beaten the   school” on nights and weekends. It’s
 for 3 minutes. Then I use the data   subjects and grade levels. I’ve   sentences, and more. The Fast and   you? Most of the time, nothing. It   entire class by thousands of dollars   not actually the case. We assume

 24                                                                                                         25
   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29   30